The Talent Management Collective
Judgment20 min per nominee, 30 min to set up

Potential Evidence Audit

Before the talent review, test every 'high potential' call against the evidence and the future role.

When to use it

  • Before a talent review or calibration session
  • Before naming people to a succession slate or high-potential program
  • When the same kinds of people keep appearing in the top boxes

Why it matters

Talent decisions are judgments, and judgments about potential are the shakiest of all. Potential is often rated without saying what it is potential for, and performance, visibility and likability stand in for it. Surveys of high-potential programs show low employee trust in their fairness. Sharna Wiblen's work makes the underlying point plainly: talent decisions are always subjective, so the task is to make them deliberate and evidenced rather than pretend they are objective.

This audit separates evidence of performance from evidence of potential, grades the quality of that evidence, and asks who is missing from the list.

How it works

Define the future role and its requirements first. Then, for each nominee, record evidence of performance and evidence of potential separately, grade the evidence, run the bias checks, and look for people who should be in the conversation and are not.

Key ideas

Potential for what?Name the role, scope and time frame, and what the strategy will need from it
Evidence qualityObserved or reported? A pattern or one moment? One rater or several?
Bias checksSimilarity, recency, halo, proximity to senior leaders, 'presence' as a proxy
Who's missing?Hidden performers, remote staff, people without a sponsor

The steps

  1. Potential for whatWhat future role or scope are you assessing potential for? What will that role require in two to three years, given the strategy?
  2. The nomineesList the nominees by initials or role.
  3. Performance evidenceFor each nominee, what is the evidence of strong current performance?
  4. Potential evidenceSeparately, what is the evidence of potential for the future role, such as learning in unfamiliar territory, handling larger scope, or leading through people they don't manage?
  5. Evidence qualityFor each, is the evidence observed or second-hand, a pattern or a single moment, from one rater or several?
  6. Bias checkWhere might similarity, recency, halo, proximity to senior leaders, or 'presence' be standing in for potential?
  7. Who's missingWho should be in this conversation and isn't? Consider hidden performers and people without a sponsor.
  8. Confidence and next evidenceHow confident are you in each call, and what evidence would change your mind?
Earlier in your careerRun it on your own client group's nominations before calibration and bring the gaps you find.
Senior leaders and CHROsMake it the required pre-read for every calibration and track whether the evidence standard changes who is named.