When to use it
- You are about to launch a retention bonus, rating change, new policy or program
- A fix worked at first and then faded or backfired
- You need to show leaders the second-order effects of a decision they favor
Why it matters
People adapt to every talent policy, and they adapt in ways the designer did not plan. A retention bonus keeps people until the cliff and then the cohort leaves together. A forced rating curve sharpens differentiation and quietly ends collaboration. Systems thinkers call these recurring shapes archetypes. Naming the archetype in advance lets you design around it.
The timing matters as much as the effect. The benefit of most talent fixes shows up in weeks, while the cost shows up in six to eighteen months, after the program has been declared a success.
How it works
Describe the fix and its intended effect. List everyone who will adapt to it and how. Look six to eighteen months out for delayed effects, match what you find to an archetype, and redesign before launch.
Key ideas
Fixes that failA retention bonus keeps people to the cliff, then a cohort leaves together and expectations rise
Shifting the burdenHiring senior talent externally fills gaps fast and lets internal development wither
Success to the successfulThe high-potential label brings more opportunity, which confirms the label, while others disengage
Eroding goalsRatings drift upward each cycle until the scale stops meaning anything
Tragedy of the commonsEvery manager holds on to strong people, so the enterprise talent pool shrinks
The steps
- The fixWhat talent fix is proposed or in place? Who is sponsoring it?
- Intended effectWhat should it achieve, and how quickly would you see it?
- Who adapts, and howWho will respond to this fix: employees, managers, recruiters, competitors? How might each adapt or game it?
- Delayed effectsWhat could show up six to eighteen months from now?
- ArchetypeWhich archetype does this resemble? Write the loop in one sentence.
- RedesignHow could you change the fix so it addresses the cause as well as the symptom?
- Early warningsWhat signals would tell you the fix is starting to fail?
Earlier in your careerRun it on any policy you are asked to implement, so you can raise risks early and specifically.
Senior leaders and CHROsRun it with the executive sponsor before approval. It turns 'HR is being cautious' into a shared look at consequences.