When to use it
- The organization swings between two approaches every few years
- Two leaders argue opposite positions and both have a point
- A policy debate keeps returning in a slightly different form
Why it matters
Some talent questions are problems with an answer. Others are polarities: two interdependent goods that each need the other over time. Build or buy talent, differentiate or include, standardize or personalize, keep good people in their roles or release them to the enterprise. Barry Johnson's polarity management shows that choosing one side produces its downsides, which then pushes the organization back to the other side, and the cycle repeats.
Talent functions feel this more than most. A decade of pendulum swings, from forced ranking to no ratings and back, is what happens when a polarity is treated as a problem.
How it works
Name both poles neutrally. Map the upside and the downside of over-focus for each. Locate where you are now, then set action steps to get both upsides and measurable early warnings for both downsides.
Key ideas
Build ↔ BuyDevelop internally / hire externally
Differentiate ↔ IncludeInvest in the few / develop the many
Hold ↔ ReleaseKeep strong people in role / move them across the enterprise
Standardize ↔ PersonalizeOne fair process / fit to the person
Automate ↔ ApprenticeLet AI do the work / keep work people learn from
Accountability ↔ DevelopmentAct on underperformance / invest in growth
The steps
- Name the tensionWhat is the tension? Name both poles in neutral, positive terms.
- UpsidesWhat does each pole give you when it's working well?
- Downsides of over-focusWhat goes wrong when the organization leans too far toward each pole?
- Where are we nowWhich downside are you living in now? Who in the organization is pulling toward each pole?
- Action stepsWhat will you do to get the upside of each pole at the same time?
- Early warningsWhat measurable signs will tell you you're sliding into either downside?
- Purpose and fearWhat higher purpose do both poles serve, and what is the deeper fear if the tension is managed badly?
Earlier in your careerUse it to understand a debate between two leaders you support, and to explain both sides fairly.
Senior leaders and CHROsUse it to end a recurring argument at the top table and replace it with shared warning signs.