When to use it
- Promoting someone into a critical or newly shaped role
- Choosing a successor, restructuring a team, or retaining talent through an acquisition
- A decision has momentum and nobody is voicing doubts
Why it matters
Gary Klein's pre-mortem asks a team to assume a decision has already failed and explain why. It works because it makes raising risks the assignment rather than an act of disloyalty. People decisions benefit more than most, because the risks often sit outside the person: the role was badly designed, the sponsor left, the span was too wide, or the team was never prepared.
With spans of control widening, many promotions now put people into larger, flatter roles than their predecessors held. That makes the role and context worth testing as carefully as the candidate.
How it works
State the decision. Jump eighteen months ahead and write the failure story. List the reasons across person, role, sponsor, team and context. Then decide what to change now and what to watch.
Key ideas
PersonSkills, motivation, derailers under pressure
RoleScope, span, clarity, what changed from the last incumbent
SponsorWho backs them, and what happens if that person leaves
Team and contextWho resents it, what market or strategy shifts could hit
The steps
- The decisionWhat decision is about to be made, by whom, and by when?
- The failure storyIt is 18 months from now and the decision has clearly failed. Write what happened as a short story.
- ReasonsList every plausible reason for the failure across person, role, sponsor, team and context.
- Most likely and most damagingWhich reasons are most likely, and which would do the most damage?
- What to change nowWhat can you change before or alongside the decision to reduce those risks?
- Early warningsWhat signals at 30, 90 and 180 days would tell you it's going wrong?
- DecideProceed, proceed with conditions, or pause? Record the conditions.
Earlier in your careerRun it quietly on decisions you're implementing and offer two specific safeguards.
Senior leaders and CHROsRun it with the decision-makers before any critical appointment, and record the decision with its conditions.