The Talent Management Collective
Sense and Respond15–25 min

Talent Problem Triage

Sort a talent challenge by the kind of problem it is, so you choose an approach that fits.

When to use it

  • At the start of any talent initiative
  • When stakeholders argue about approach because they are describing different kinds of problem
  • When a vendor is selling a best practice for something nobody understands yet

Why it matters

Talent functions are built for problems with known answers. Payroll, compliance and benefits reward best practice. But many of today's talent questions, such as how to redesign entry-level work around AI or why managers hold on to their best people, have no known answer. They can only be understood by trying things and watching what happens.

This tool uses the Cynefin framework and the distinction between technical and adaptive problems. Most real challenges contain parts of each kind, so the most useful move is to split the problem and handle each part differently.

How it works

Describe the challenge, answer four diagnostic questions, then split it into parts and place each part. Match the approach to the domain, and name the mistake you are most at risk of making.

Key ideas

ClearKnown answer. Apply best practice. Example: fixing a broken approval workflow in the HRIS.
ComplicatedAnswer exists but needs expertise. Analyze. Example: validating an assessment of potential, benchmarking pay.
ComplexCause and effect only visible in hindsight. Run small experiments. Example: AI and entry-level roles, talent hoarding, culture.
ChaoticHarm is happening now. Act to stabilize first. Example: a sudden wave of leadership exits or a leaked restructuring.

The steps

  1. The challengeDescribe the talent challenge in two or three sentences.
  2. Four diagnostic questionsIs there a known right answer that someone already has? Would experts agree on it? Will we only understand cause and effect in hindsight? Is harm happening right now?
  3. Split itBreak the challenge into parts. Which parts are clear, complicated, complex or chaotic?
  4. Approach for each partFor each part, what approach fits, and who should own it?
  5. The likely mistakeWhat mistake is your organization most likely to make with this challenge?
Earlier in your careerUse it before you build anything, and share your read with your manager. It shows judgment beyond execution.
Senior leaders and CHROsUse it to set expectations with the executive team about which parts can be planned and which must be learned.